Word and Hope · Sermon Articles

Confession & Repentance

The Conversation You Keep Rehearsing

You know you need to have the conversation. Here's why Christians stall anyway, and what Jesus actually calls us to do about it.

Two women sitting on a bench outdoors, having a serious, honest conversation

There's something sitting in your chest. Not a decision exactly, more like a weight you keep trying to ignore. A quiet, nagging feeling that you need to talk to him. Or her. You haven't let yourself say it out loud yet, because once you do, you know what comes next.

The excuses come quick, one after another. You don't want to be a bother. You don't want to be the difficult one, the extra one, the person who makes something out of nothing. Maybe it really is all in your head. Maybe you're the problem for even wanting to bring it up, since in this culture, the one who speaks up is the one who gets blamed for the conflict, not the one who gets thanked for the honesty.

So you open your Bible, half looking for clarity and half looking for a way out. You land on a verse about overlooking an offense, about love covering a multitude of sins, and something in you grabs onto it fast, gratefully, before you've really wrestled with what it means.

Maybe this is one of those times you're just supposed to let it go. You almost believe it. Your chest doesn't quite agree.

A Command We Already Know

This is the quiet experience of so many Christians. Scripture tells us exactly what to do here. We could probably quote the verses ourselves. We might complain to someone else about it, but we rarely bring it to the person themselves. Why do we find that so difficult?

Jesus tells us plainly what to do. In Matthew 18, if your brother sins against you, you go to him and tell him his fault, between the two of you alone. He gives the same instruction in reverse in Matthew 5: if you're bringing your gift to the altar and you remember someone has something against you, leave the gift right there and go make it right first, before you finish worshiping.

“If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained your brother.”

Matthew 18:15

The scripture here is extremely clear. And for Christians who hold the scriptures as authoritative, even for us, this still feels sometimes impossible. Why do we struggle so much with obeying something so plain?

What We're Actually Protecting

Nobody wakes up looking forward to a hard conversation. We avoid hard things. But if we're honest, it isn't really the other person's comfort we're protecting when we avoid it. It's our own. We don't want to feel the awkwardness, we don't want to risk being disliked, we don't want to sit in the tension of a conversation that might go badly. Call it what it is: self-protection, dressed up and mistaken for love.

But something else gets layered on top of that. Our culture has quietly redefined kindness. We've watched people lose their jobs, their friendships, their whole reputations, simply for saying something that made someone else uncomfortable, whether or not what they said was even true. So the lesson gets absorbed fast: discomfort itself is treated as proof of harm, and whoever caused it becomes the villain of the story. We've traded real compassion, the kind that tells people the truth, for something that only looks like compassion from the outside. The reality is that we fear man more than we fear God.


Not a Feeling to Manage, But a Call to Obey

The weight you've been carrying in your chest, that unsettled, unresolved thing, is not meant to live there forever. God did not design the human soul to rehearse conflict in the shower and call it patience. He did not intend for that message to sit in your drafts while you wait for a courage that never quite arrives on its own.

This is not a feeling to manage. It is a call to obey.

Jesus was not subtle about it. He said go. Not feel better about it. Not wait until the timing is right. Go. And the staggering mercy in that command is that he does not send you alone. He sends himself with you.

So stop circling it. Say the thing. Send the message. Whatever it takes. The tension was never yours to just carry. It was yours to bring.

Matthew Schaefer

Pastor, First Baptist Church of Wellston

Matthew is a pastor at First Baptist Church of Wellston and a biblical counselor through Word and Hope, where he walks alongside people working through exactly these kinds of conversations. He is married and has four children, whom he and his wife homeschool.